In my original, initial report, as discussed above, which was “finalized” in January 2026, I found that the Champlain lobe persisted as a long convex lobe in T7 and Fort Ann time, continuing into late glacial T8 time, with a readvance in T8 time following the incursion of the Champlain Sea. This interpretation was based on diverse evidence, including the correlation of readvance evidence reported by Wright (2009) in the Charlotte area and Connally (1970) in the Bridport area, with readvance evidence in the Missisquoi Basin in Champlain Sea time, as reported by Cannon (1964) and Wagner (1972). The correlation of these readvances, plus other correlative information, resulted in an interpretation of a long convex late glacial lobe in both T7 and T8 times, with Bridport and Charlotte being located relatively far to the south in the Champlain Basin. Both Fort Ann and Champlain Sea waters occupied a narrow, more or less open water corridor along the T7 and T8 ice margins, giving this lobe a long, convex shape, such that the readvance was believed to have been relatively limited and minor.
As discussed in the pre-Addendum report, the concept of a long convex lobe with a late glacial readvance at such a late time evolved progressively, almost reluctantly, as a matter of fitting together multiple pieces of evidence. As was recognized, this finding flies in the face of conventional thinking about the configuration of the receding ice margin as a flattened, calving lobe, as suggested by Chapman and many other subsequent researchers, with the ice margin in Champlain Sea time commonly thought to be located north of the Quebec border in Fort Ann time to allow for the incursion of the Sea. Of course, as was also noted, until this present study the positions of the ice margins in Vermont have been inferred, based on an assumed preconception about the nature of the Champlain lobe and its recession in relation to proglacial water levels, but not directly and explicitly based on actual ice margin evidence. The evolution in my thinking and associated evidence leading to the interpretation of a long convex lobe at a late glacial time is described in the pre-Addendum January 2026 report above and is not repeated here.
Also as mentioned above, discussions with David Franzi near the end of my January study about such a long late glacial lobe were helpful. David expressed skepticism about the presence of a long convex lobe and readvance at such a late time based on evidence in the New York side of the basin and as well on published theoretical profiles for receding ice sheet lobes which suggest to him that such a long convex lobe, especially a readvance at such a late time, is physically unsustainable. My response to David was first in regard to the New York evidence, that I believed the lobe was “schizophrenic,” with the recession on the New York side of the basin being very different from the Vermont side owing to physiographic differences which promoted earlier and more substantial calving on the western side of the basin. And second, I suggested that in regard to his profile argument, perhaps the presence of a long late convex lobe may have reflected the lingering presence of ice from its former more substantial extent. And I speculated that perhaps this lobe may have been mostly stagnant with oscillatory spasms or pulses to account for the “readvance” interpretations reported by Connally and Wright as part of the long late convex lobe interpretation. I even found literature identifying such spasms in otherwise dead ice which fit with this thinking. Obviously, I was doing my best to both accommodate David’s thinking and arguments, while clinging to my long lobe interpretation, in respect to the accumulated evidence in support of this interpretation.
David provided me a report that he recently published,1Franzi, David A., Sean Grasing, Emily McLean, David Barclay, and Jason Briner.“Bridging the Gap: Glacial Geomorphic Mapping in the Adirondack Upland, New York.” Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs, Vol. 58, No. 2 (2026).DOI: 10.1130/abs/2026NE-12821. showing the configuration of moraines and other features documenting the progressive recession of the ice margin and the associated development of proglacial water bodies in northwestern New York. It is interesting to note that this report is based substantially on LiDAR imagery. It strikes me that just as the usage of such imagery in Vermont for me has revolutionized the way we look at deglacial history, Franzi et al’s report likewise shows the benefit of LiDAR. Whereas the specific types of ice margin features in New York differ from those found here in Vermont, in general a similar step-down recession in New York is indicated. Franzi et al identify a major end moraine, referred to as “Covey Hill-Ellenburg-Plattsburgh Ice Margin (CHEP)” which wraps around the terrain showing an ice lobe occupying the Ontario Basin and extending southward in the Champlain Basin. As discussed in the Appendix, David has provided me with several reports that document the presence of multiple receding lobe ice margins in the Champlain Basin, which I used to get a sense of possible correlations with receding margins in Vermont.
Significantly, Franzi,Carl, Pepperstone, and Gordon, 2023, 2 Franzi,D., Carl, B., Pepperstone, H. and Gordon, C. 2023, NEW INSIGHTS INTO THE INTERRELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN LATE PLEISTOCENE–Early Holocene proglacial lake and marine water bodies in the St. Lawrence and Champlain valleys in New York, Vermont, and adjacent Canada, GSA Abstract Joint 72nd Annual Southeastern/ 58th Annual Northeastern Section Meeting – 2023, Paper # 44-1. indicate that the “breakout” of Lake Iroquois in the Ontario Basin into the Champlain Basin was associated with, and in fact triggered the lowering of Lake Vermont from the Coveville to the Fort Ann level, with the ice margin then standing at Covey Hill. Franzi, et al 3 Franzi, D. A., Ridge, J. C., Pair, D. L., DeSimone, D. J., Rayburn, J. A., & Barclay, D. J. (2016). Post-Valley Heads deglaciation of the Adirondack Mountains and adjacent lowlands. Adirondack Journal of Environmental Studies, 21(1), 119–146. provide illustrations depicting the ice margins in the Ontario and Champlain Basins in Coveville and Fort Ann times.

It is noted that the position of the Champlain lobe tip as depicted above in Coveville and Fort Ann times is restricted to the northern Champlain Basin. According to Franzi (2025) personal communication) he believes that the ice margin in the Champlain Basin in Fort Ann time was flattened by calving, resulting in the ice margin in subsequent Champlain Sea time standing further north in Quebec. Further, he indicates that the depiction of this flattened lobe extending across the basin into Vermont is schematic.
Also, discussions with Etienne Brouard were likewise helpful. Brouard provided me with a recent report he co-authored (Cormier, et al.,4 Cormier, M.-A., Lajeunesse, P., Brouard, E., & Bernier, J.-F. (2025). “Revisiting retreat patterns of the Laurentide Ice Sheet margin during the Late Pleistocene in southern Québec using LiDAR imagery.” Geoscience Canada, 52(2), 119. DOI: 10.12789/geocanj.2025.52.223. stating:
“Since the 1800s, the deglaciation record has been investigated mostly by mapping of surficial deposits and landforms from air photo interpretation and field observations. The deglacial patterns and its dynamics in the Appalachian and St. Lawrence lowlands sectors are still poorly understood today, due to the limitations of these previous approaches in a dense forest cover.”
Their findings likewise refer to the benefit of LiDAR and recognize the importance of Glacial Dynamics, as for example a distinction between Cold versus Warm based ice. The authors recognize step-down recessional ice margin positions as depicted by various moraines formed in close association with proglacial water bodies, and identify several climatically driven readvances. According to Brouard (2026, personal communication), the evidence in southern Quebec may be compatible with a narrow, open water corridor along the receding ice margin leading to the lowering of Lake Fort Ann and the opening of the basin for the incursion of the Champlain Sea, which I take as supporting the concept of a long convex Champlain lobe in Fort Ann and perhaps Champlain Sea times.
In any case, the finding of a long, convex lobe at such a late time as presented in the January 2026 version was uncertain and, so to speak on “thin ice,” and deserved to be re-examined. The above January 2026 report was completed with the issue regarding the nature, shape, and extent of the receding Champlain lobe in T7 and T8 time left unresolved. Thus, I subsequently decided to take a closer look at this issue, first by more detailed study of VCGI map evidence, especially using LiDAR imagery, followed by focused field examination of selected critical features. This Addendum summarizes these findings.
To help the reader place these findings in perspective, the following is a map, taken from the pre-Addendum January 2026 report, and the map on the right is from the Addendum study.

The above map left and associated deglacial history findings are discussed in detail in the pre-Addendum report and are not repeated here. Suffice it to say, as can seen, both the late glacial T7 and T8 time Champlain lobes are mapped as extending far to the south in the basin. It is this finding that led to a discussion with Dave Franzi, which was then followed by the Addendum study, resulting in the revision as shown on the above map on the right.
Again, the addendum map is discussed in detail below, and is not repeated here. As can be seen, whereas the Champlain lobe stood far to the south in early T7 time, owing to significant Glacial Dynamics, this lobe receded rapidly in two phases of streaming in T7 time, the latter with accelerated streaming and possibly a collapse(?) of the Champlain lobe, with calving recession of the ice margin to and beyond the Quebec border. As depicted, the revised Addendum interpretation marks a T8 readvance back into Vermont in Champlain Sea time, with the readvance restricted to the Missisquoi Basin.
The Addendum revision to the glacial history came from the identification of features associated with Glacial Dynamics, which caused the rapid recession of the Champlain lobe. Briefly, by way of an advance preview of the Addendum findings, the map below is presented, with an explanation in the following:

This map represents the Champlain lobe in late T6 and early T7 time beginning when Coveville Lake Vermont fell to the Fort Ann level. To step back, as per the pre-Addendum findings, the Champlain lobe recession was a progressive, step-down type from late T3 time in the beginning of the Lobate Phase, with the receding ice margins fronted by standing waters of progressively coalescing and enlarging proglacial lakes. In late T6 time the frontal tip of the Champlain lobe was bifurcated with an eastern prong in the Vermont Valley near Rutland and a western prong on the main basin floor, west of the nose of the Taconics, fronted by Coveville Lake Vermont. Coveville waters were confined in a narrow corridor along a Disaggregated type ice margin. The position of the head of the corridor was diachronic, progressively extending northward in late T6 and Coveville time, reaching the vicinity of the Winooski Basin, when Coveville fell to the Fort Ann level.
The Coveville to Fort Ann lowering was both sudden and substantial. The above map represents multiple events in T7 and Fort Ann time. The pre-Addendum study identified Ribbed Lacustrine, Headless Delta, and Thickened Bouldery Lacustrine deposits which document the ice margin where and when this lowering occurred at the time of the late T6 to T7 transition. These deposits also document calving of narrow ice masses within re-entrant basins in the Middlebury Bench, as identified on the above map. The blue line marks the Fort Ann strandline, with the closely associated T7 ice margin prior to this recession.
The Addendum study identified LiDAR features termed “Streaks,” as discussed below, which indicate that the entire Champlain lobe in Vermont was “jolted” by the Coveville to Fort Ann lowering at the late T6 to T7 time transition. It is likely that this also was associated with the sudden incursion of standing water from Lake Iroquois at the Covey Hill breakout, and also drainage of a major standing water body in the interior uplands in the Winooski and Lamoille Basins. This “jolt,” represented a Glacial Dynamic, resulting in Destabilization of the Champlain lobe, again as marked by Streaks.
The evidence indicates that by T7 time the Champlain lobe in Vermont had become substantially Warm, as indicated by the absence of Ice Marginal Channels at this time. Likewise, the base of the ice sheet had become warmed by substantial meltwater penetration to the base of the Champlain lobe in the form of both thin water films which permitted seepage, and as well substantial discrete basal channels or tunnels, again as documented by evidence discussed in detail elsewhere herein. It is surmised that basal waters within and beneath the ice sheet were hydrostatically confined by a low permeability, confining Cold stratum, such that the sudden and substantial lowering of Coveville to Fort Ann water levels resulted in a pressure perturbation, or jolt, to the entire Champlain lobe. Again, this hypothesis is presented to account for the presence of Streaks which are identified widely in the Champlain Basin, including as far north as the Missisquoi Basin, even though the northernmost position of Lake Vermont at the time of the transiton from Coveville to Fort Ann was near Burlington. Whether or not Streaks exist in New York and Quebec is not known.
The recession of the ice margin in T7 time was diachronic in two directions or ways in the horizontal perspective. The evidence documents the progressive northward penetration of the head of Fort Ann waters in its narrow Disaggregated corridor with time, eventually extending to the Quebec border and beyond. Again, the blue line on the above map represents the Fort Ann strandline at the time of the transition from late T6 to early T7 time, associated with this corridor.
Regarding the second way or direction, the ice margin associated with the Fort Ann corridor also widened in T7 time, in conjunction with the recessional calving in the re-entrant basins. As discussed in the pre-Addendum study, in early- and mid-T7 and Fort Ann time, the frontal tips of narrow ice masses in the re-entrant basins in the Middlebury Bench receded progressively westward by calving, again as documented by specific types of deposits. At this time, the Middlebury Bench remained ice covered, with calving recession of lobe tips in the re-entrant basins. The Bench and associated re-entrant basins are shown on the above map, but the scale of the map precludes showing the recession of individual re-entrant ice margin tips. In essence, at this time the Bench provided buttressing support for the Champlain lobe. The evidence indicates that the uplands of the Middlebury Bench were eroded and scraped by the ice, leaving very thin and only patchy till, with the eroded material likely serving as a sediment supply for the narrow calving ice masses in the re-entrant basins.
Also, the presence of Lake Vermont in a narrow Disaggregated ice margin corridor, along the Champlain lobe margin first in Coveville time and then in Fort Ann time, served to destabilize the eastern margin of the lobe resulting in the transformation of this margin from a lateral type margin toward a frontal type margin, as suggested by Ice Tongue Grooves, as discussed in the pre-Addendum report, which likewise are part of the documentation for the progressive diachronic northward penetration and widening of the corridor along the eastern margin of the Champlain lobe through time.
By mid-T7 time, the Champlain lobe lowered and receded westward, with its margin along the Trough, which is a lower, flatter portion of the Champlain floor, west of the Middlebury Bench. The margin of the Trough is shown by the white line on the above map. Multiple factors resulted or contributed to destabilization at this time, leading to a first phase of ice streaming and associated calving of the T7 lobe tip: 5The Trough boundary is very close to the Champlain Sea marine limit strandline. In the pre-Addendum report, it was found that the lowering of Fort Ann to the Champlain Sea, which likewise was sudden and substantiaal, occurred in T8 time, with the ice margin then standing essentially at the Champlain Sea strandline, which is close to the Trough boundary.
- The loss of buttressing support formerly provided by the Middlebury Bench, with the ice margin now standing along the margin of the Trough.
- The chute-like shape of the Trough physiography.
- The presence of erodible shales beneath the Trough.
- The presence of substantial meltwater both along the ice margin and beneath the ice.
As a result of these factors, the Champlain lobe began a first phase of ice streaming at this time. This first phase of streaming is marked by “Scarps,” which are very numerous “Signature” type features, essentially mapped along the Trough margin (again the white line on the above map). These are interpreted as Lateral Shear Margin features formed by first phase of streaming. Further, the “readvance” evidence reported by Wright in Charlotte and Connally in West Bridport are now interpreted as representing shearing along the lateral shear margin. The base of the Scarps is everywhere close to but above the Champlain Sea strandline, which makes clear that this first phase of streaming was in Fort Ann time.
The head of this first phase of streaming is marked by a pivot point and Onset Zone located at the northwest corner of the Middlebury Bench, which served as a restriction and buttressing support for the Champlain lobe at this time. Mega-Scale Lineations associated with this streaming and a Transverse Morainic Ridge marking a pause in the northward recession of the calving Champlain lobe tip are also identified, again as discussed below.
As noted below, Scarps are everywhere mapped close to the Champlain Sea strandline at the marine limit, but in all cases at a slightly higher elevation. In as much as the Scarps are regarded as the base of the lateral shear margin of ice streaming, the bases of Scarps therefore formed on the bed of the ice sheet along its margin, below the elevation of the ice surface, and thus must pre-date the Champlain Sea.
Whereas Scarps are numerous in the southern Champlain Basin, south of the Onset Zone, they are scant or non-existent north of the Onset Zone, which is attributed to a second, accelerated phase of ice streaming associated with the sudden and substantial lowering of the Fort Ann level to the Champlain Sea. Further, erosional gouges on the Onset Zone at elevations descending from the Fort Ann level to the Champlain Sea level are interpreted as formed by ice gouging along the lateral shear margin at the time of lowering from Fort Ann to Champlain Sea levels. In a sense, these gouges represent the breaking of the ice dam at the Onset Zone in a manner analogous to surface water dam breaks. These gouges thus mark the position of the frontal tip of the Champlain lobe at the time of the lowering of Fort Ann to the Champlain Sea, marking the incursion of the Champlain Sea. The absence of Scarps north of the Onset Zone is taken as the absence of any cohesive ice margin as is typical of a “collapse.”
This “collapse(?)” led to the rapid recession of the Champlain lobe at the end of T7 and Fort Ann time northward to and beyond the Quebec border, again as documented by the absence of Scarps north of the Onset Zone, and as well extensive bouldery lacustrine and marine deposits northward to the border, indicative of calving recession.
The evidence of a readvance as previously reported by Wright in the Charlotte area and by Connally in the Bridport area are here interpreted as formed by the lateral shear margin associated with this first phase of ice streaming. Accordingly, the evidence of a readvance reported by Cannon and Wagner in the Missisquoi Basin is now interpreted as representing a readvance restricted to this basin in T8 time, after the initial incursion of the Champlain Sea. As discussed below, according to Parent (2023), a readvance at this time identified in Quebec may have temporarily reclosed the basin.
Whether or not similar evidence exists in support of the above features, deglacial history, and Glacial Dynamics in New York and Quebec as just described is unknown. However, as discussed below, recent reports in Ontario conceptually support the finding of two phases of ice streaming with an accelerated second phase. In Ontario this second phase is referred to as a “collapse.”
These finding resolve the issue of a long convex lobe at a late glacial time, albeit in an unexpected way related to Glacial Dynamics.
This entire study for me has been a learning experience, in a sense with multiple epiphanies. In my Preface I offered a comment about epiphanies and paradigms, which bears repeating:
“This is the story of the deglacial history of Vermont, across the entire State, including suggested possible correlations with neighboring Quebec, New York, and New Hampshire. This has never been done before. For me, my revisit was a “voyage of discovery,” poetically speaking, finding new information, with many “epiphanies.” These epiphanies represented “a ha” moments when I suddenly understood and grasped the meaning of certain evidence. And further, these epiphanies morphed into a new paradigm understanding of Vermont deglacial history. Recognizing the need to document the basis for my findings in detail as factual evidence as my voyage progressed, I was forced to write, not knowing where this exploration was taking me. As a consequence, this report became overly long and needs to be condensed into a summary of its essence. But the details given provide documentation of the basis for my findings in this present version for the benefit of future researchers.
I refer to “paradigms,” which are powerful ways of processing information, at the very heart of human thinking. But at times our paradigms limit our ability to see and understand what is before our eyes, becoming so-called paradigm “traps.” It turns out that satisfying my curiosity required imagination to explore the evidence I was finding, hence the quotes on the frontispiece of this report. These quotes are not intended to signify that others before or after me in the 1970s lacked imagination. Rather, they serve to remind me that my personal lack of imagination was a failing. Back then, in the old days, I could have done a better job, if only… ! But, of course, it’s always easy to look back. For me, my “a ha” epiphanies thus led to a “paradigm shift,” a new and different understanding of Vermont deglacial history.
I think of my entire research experience as very much like solving a gigantic three-dimensional puzzle in which some of the puzzle pieces are missing and many need to be carefully studied to be understood, with time as an additional part of the puzzle.”
One of these epiphanies for me had to do with how late in time in the glacial history, and how brief the time was for the recessional history of the ice sheet in Vermont was. In as much as: a) the late T3 ice margin is correlated with the White Mountain Morainic System in New Hampshire, which has been dated as about 13,800 -14000 years BP, and b) the incursion of the Champlain Sea into Vermont has been dated as about 13,000 years BP, therefore the recession of the ice margins was quite fast, which fits with and supports the concept of a collapse.
Many of these epiphanies have to do with Glacial Dynamics. It turns out that the Addendum study showed that Glacial Dynamics played a major role in the late times of the Champlain lobe. Thus, in the text below a discussion is added about Glacial Dynamics. Finally, as the Addendum study progressed it became increasingly clear that the Vermont story needs to be told in a broader regional context, and accordingly a discussion is added about the regional perspective. Finally, as the Addendum study progressed it became increasingly clear that the Vermont story needs to be told in a broader regional context, and accordingly a discussion is added about the regional perspective.
Organizationally, this Addendum includes the following:
- LiDAR imagery findings
- Results of follow-up focused field work
- A summary of the Addendum findings in the southern and central Champlain Basin
- Revised deglacial history of the entire State of Vermont
- Glacial Dynamics Epiphanies
- A regional perspective
Footnotes